OHSAA public-private playoff split headed for statewide vote

· Yahoo Sports

The Suburban League, a conference of 16 schools in Northeast Ohio, has officially gotten the ball rolling on a public-private divide for high school playoffs.

Visit somethingsdifferent.biz for more information.

The league submitted a petition for a membership vote on separate tournaments for public and private schools to the Ohio High School Athletic Association on Nov. 16. The petition received 152 signatures, well exceeding the required 75-signature threshold.

Now, the question of whether public and private schools should compete in separate postseason tournaments will go to a vote for OHSAA member institutions. The OHSAA's next referendum period begins in May 2027, with each high school voting on all ballot proposals from May 1 to May 15. There are 691 public-school and 121 private-school OHSAA members, each of whose principals cast a vote in the referendum period.

If approved in May, separate state tournaments would likely be implemented for the 2028-2029 school year. According to the National Federation of State High School Associations (NFHS), only Alabama, Maryland, Texas, and Virginia currently hold separate public and private high school state tournaments.

This isn't the first time the question of public vs. private athletics has been brought to the OHSAA's members for a vote. Petition attempts in 1978 and 1993 both failed, but renewed discussion over disproportionate private-school titles led to the development of the OHSAA's competitive balance plan in 2014.

OHSAA member schools adopted competitive balance measures beginning in 2017, placing schools in appropriate postseason divisions for baseball, basketball, football, soccer, softball, and volleyball.

The competitive balance formula looks at a school's enrollment and assigns each rostered player a tier based on considerations like which school district the student lives in or whether they come from an assigned feeder school. The OHSAA then adjusts the enrollment count accordingly, with more local players lowering the enrollment number and more out-of-district players raising it. That adjusted enrollment figure then determines the school's tournament division.

Competitive balance has had some success at bringing state titles closer to a proportionate public-private split. In football, for example, private schools won over 50% of the state championships in the 16 years before the plan's implementation. Since 2017, private schools have won just 20% of the football titles.

While nearly every sport has seen more public schools win championships since competitive balance was adopted, some sports still seem to favor private schools. Girls volleyball has hardly been affected as private schools have won over 64% of state titles since 2017, with three Greater Cincinnati-based private schools winning this year alone. Both boys soccer (48%) and girls soccer (42%) also see high rates of private schools titles.

In OHSAA fall 2026 state finals so far, public schools won four of seven titles in volleyball, four of five titles in boys soccer and three of five titles in girls soccer.

What percent of competitively balanced sports have been won by public vs. private schools?

Here are the state championships won by public vs. private schools in the OHSAA from the 1999-2000 year through the 2016-17 year, according to the competitive balance report.

SPORTPUBLIC CHAMPIONSPRIVATE CHAMPIONSFootball55 (49.1%)57 (50.9%)Girls volleyball29 (40.3%)43 (59.7%)Boys soccer20 (37.7%)33 (62.3%)Girls soccer15 (35.7%)27 (64.3%)Boys basketball45 (62.5%)27 (37.5%)Girls basketball42 (58.3%)30 (41.7%)Baseball42 (58.3%)30 (41.7%)Softball67 (94.4%)4 (5.6%)Total315 (55.7%)251 (44.3%)

Now, here is the same breakdown from 2017-18 through 2025-26, or the competitive balance era.

SPORTPUBLIC CHAMPIONSPRIVATE CHAMPIONSFootball50 (79.4%)13 (20.6%)Girls volleyball15 (35.7%)27 (64.3%)Boys soccer16 (51.6%)15 (48.4%)Girls soccer18 (58.1%)13 (41.9%)Boys basketball23 (60.5%)15 (39.5%)Girls basketball28 (73.7%)10 (26.3%)Baseball26 (68.4%)12 (31.6%)Softball36 (94.7%)2 (5.3%)Total212 (66.5%)107 (33.5%)

Though not directly tied to the public-private debate, in 2024 the OHSAA expanded the number of divisions in many sports to alleviate enrollment discrepancies within each division. Previously, some divisions saw schools compete with enrollment differences of over 1,000 students.

This article originally appeared on Cincinnati Enquirer: OHSAA public-private playoff split headed for statewide vote

Read full story at source