5 questions, 5 answers: Florida State lays an egg with bowl eligibility hanging by a thread
· Yahoo Sports
Florida State football (5-6, 3-5 ACC) no-showed in the second half against NC State (5-6, 3-5 ACC), getting outscored 21-0 en route to a 28-10 defeat. The Seminoles now must beat rival Florida on a short week to become bowl eligible, or else FSU will miss out on postseason play for the third straight season.
Visit mchezo.life for more information.
Either the interim-coach bump wearing off or the ever-growing injury list, most likely both, finally caught up to Florida State as Rick Stockstill’s team was outgained 464-283 and picked up 10 fewer first downs.
It was one of the more disappointing results of the season — which is saying something — after FSU had won two road games in a row and seemed to finally have momentum on their side. The TN team breaks down what went wrong for the Seminoles and whether they have a shot against Florida next Friday.
After winning two in a row and being a 10.5-point favorite, how disappointing was this FSU performance?
- Tony Morris: Very disappointing. The crowd showed up, wore the turquoise jerseys for this and even the national media believed with how much we were favored.
- Matt Minnick: I mean…it was sort of expected right? Not necessarily a double-digit loss but a really ugly performance? It’s hard to underscore that some of these players have maybe had 2-3 days worth of reps with the starters all season. What was more disappointing than the loss itself was that the offensive playcalling seemed to not even try to win. Throwing 4 yard hitches on third and 9 is not even giving yourself a chance. This was one of the worst games from a play-calling standpoint I’ve seen in years. Maybe since the Jax State game.
- Seminole Uprising: I know getting my hopes up was my own fault, but it seemed like things were changing, at least against below-average ACC teams. The Noles won two straight road games, and with a new coach, new uniforms, and one win away from bowl eligibility, NC State looked like a great place to keep building momentum. So, from that viewpoint, it was incredibly disappointing, especially how bad FSU looked after a great opening-drive score.
- Curt Weiler: It was disappointing but NC State has not been playing good football of late. But it was also a helpful reminder of the bad state of this roster, especially in its injury-depleted state.
- LastNoleofKrypton: Mildly disappointing. Only mildly because as eager as I am to see the ’Noles get back to a bowl game, I’m even more eager to be done with Ashton Daniels football.
- Perry Kostidakis: I had fully drunk the Kool-Aid, so pretty disappointing even if it was of my own actions. NC State had yet to beat an ACC team with a .500 or better record at the time of kickoff until tonight, and even with the injuries racking up for the Seminoles, there’s no way that this offense should have only produced 10 points against one of the worst defenses in the country.
Who deserves more blame, offense or defense?
- Tony Morris: Offense, I mean it’s one thing to get shutout in the second half, it is another to not even be competitive at all in moving the ball down the field.
- Matt Minnick: Offense. Unequivocally the offense. The defense made some huge plays in the first half to give you a 10-7 lead. And the O just continued to be incapable of doing anything to play complimentary football.
- Seminole Uprising: Offense. They couldn’t move the ball after the opening drive and scored zero points in the second half. They kept playing behind the sticks and posed no threat on the ground. It may have been the most anemic offensive display of the season.
- Curt Weiler: Offense. The running back depth was no doubt an issue but to easily march down the field on the opening drive and then basically do nothing the rest of the game was a bad look. I think we’re all ready for the Ashton Daniels era to come to an end.
- LastNoleofKrypton: The offense deserves 90% of the blame; you let NC State run 40+ plays in the 1st half because you couldn’t sustain drives at all and the defense wore down because of it.
- Perry Kostidakis: The defense didn’t help itself with multiple third-and-long conversions, but man, what a poor showing from Tim Harris Jr. and his quarterback. Matt touched on it already, but the offense wasn’t set up to succeed at all with conservative and unimaginative playcalling and poor execution by Ashton Daniels exacerbating it. Poor Jasen Lopez will wake up in a cold sweat tonight after a nightmare in which he has to run another screen.
How much did injuries contribute to tonight’s loss?
- Tony Morris: It was a factor for sure, our running back room was bleak and it was obvious. Daniels having 14 interceptions is insanity and now he leads all of college football.
- Matt Minnick: Significantly. Have to imagine guys like Kromah and Duce make enough plays to at least keep NC State off the field a good bit.
- Seminole Uprising: Following up on what I previously said, having none of your top-four running backs on the roster finally came to a head. On defense, the lack of Rylan Kennedy showed up, and the secondary was torched without Rawls or Jones. This team just does not have enough depth to make up for an already talent-burdened roster.
- Curt Weiler: They undeniably did. You could feel how much the pass rush missed Rylan Kennedy and having to start a partial-scholarship RB is obviously suboptimal. But I have seen plenty of FSU teams win in spite of mounting injuries so I’m not giving them a pass.
- LastNoleofKrypton: Significantly, best DT, best CB, best WR, top 4 RBs, too much to overcome with such woeful QB play.
- Perry Kostidakis: I wouldn’t fully ascribe the loss to the injuries, but their impact was felt. Being down to your fifth-string running back is not ideal, but even with the personnel losses there and Duce Robinson’s absence, you’d think that you’d get the ball in the hands of your guaranteed playmakers.
QB Ashton Daniels was laboring against NC State and clearly did not play his best game. Should he start next week?
- Tony Morris: I want to say no, but knowing how this season has went, he will. He’s our best option unfortunately, throwing one of the youngins like Sperry or Marshall in a packed rivalry game with bowl game stipulations might be too bright for them to play.
- Matt Minnick: No. He shouldn’t have started this game if we are being honest. It would be nice to at least see what Marshall brings to the table.
- Seminole Uprising: If he can go, he should. I know today was very bad. But I do not think Kevin Sperry is any better. Quarterback will be the next coach’s top priority. But for now, the Noles have to hope Daniels can make enough plays on the ground.
- Curt Weiler: He shouldn’t but it’s almost impossible to argue he won’t. Unless he’s quite banged up, I think we all expect it’ll be him next week.
- LastNoleofKrypton: He shouldn’t have started at all this season but Sperry should start next week. It’ll answer the question definitively on if you need to prioritize spending on a good QB in the portal.
- Perry Kostidakis: I understand the hesitation in not making the move in the final week of the season with not much on the line other than a bowl invite (which, while the money from playing in one is needed, the extra practices with an interim staff isn’t really), and also that this staff probably doesn’t have much need in figuring out what they have in Kevin Sperry or Malachi Marshall, but after another multi-turnover performance, I think that he should ride the pine. I don’t anticipate it happening, though.
What was your takeaway from former defensive coordinator Tony White’s mid-game post?
🤔
— Tony White (@FSUCoachTW) November 21, 2026
- Tony Morris: The biggest joke ever, didn’t like that guy before the season, during the season and now especially after. It is an complete joke and you just can’t make it up.
- Matt Minnick: He’s a clown. He coached a defense that gave up THIRTY SIX points to Clemson. Come on, man.
- Seminole Uprising: He is the reason the defense is in this spot, with poor personnel decisions and an even worse scheme that interim DC Ernie Sims tried to fix overnight. Plus, he still has friends on the staff that he took from Nebraska. So, in a word (phrase?), tone-deaf.
- Curt Weiler: That he had to wait three weeks to send it says everything. The defense undeniably got better when he left, even if the team didn’t win a third straight game today without him.
- LastNoleofKrypton: That he’s a jobless bum making fun of the kids he promised to coach and develop. Good riddance.
- Perry Kostidakis: I honestly cannot believe that he would do that to his former players and staff, to the point that I’m wondering if he started holiday celebrations a little early. It’s wildly petty and vindictive and even more so, hilarious because of the fact that he is the reason that he got fired — he had people clamoring for Adam Fuller! It’s not even burning a bridge with fans, it’s rude and disrespectful to the kids on the field that he played a hand in recruiting and developing and while I don’t like getting in the way of people’s livelihoods, it absolutely should come up the next time he starts looking for a job.