Did Paul Bernardo kill Elizabeth Bain? 'Dateline Canada' revisits the case

· Toronto Sun

See more Toronto Sun on Google — save as a Preferred Source

Visit umafrika.club for more information.

More than 35 years after Elizabeth Bain disappeared, Dateline ‘s Keith Morrison and Canadian journalist Diana Swain are revisiting a case that has left her family searching for answers.

Morrison has spent decades telling some of America’s most compelling true-crime stories. Now, he’s helping promote Dateline Canada, a spinoff of the long-running NBC true-crime series he fronts that will take a fresh look at the disappearance of the young woman who vanished after heading to the University of Toronto’s Scarborough campus on the hot afternoon of June 19, 1990.

“The first recollection I had of the case is when I saw the picture of Elizabeth. Back when we put up (missing persons) posters on poles — pre-social media, pre-Internet. I remember seeing that picture,” Swain said in an interview at a downtown Toronto television studio.

Three days after she vanished, Bain’s blood-stained car was found across from a nearby autobody shop. But despite an exhaustive search, her body has never been found.

The disappearance of the 22-year-old promising student remains one of Canada’s most puzzling murder mysteries.

Bain’s boyfriend, Robert Baltovich, was arrested five months later and convicted of her murder in 1992. Prosecutors argued that he concocted false alibis and killed her in a fit of rage after learning she planned to break up with him.

Baltovich served eight years in prison — losing his mother to cancer while he was behind bars — before being released on bail in 2000.

After his conviction was overturned in 2004, a new trial was ordered. By the time the retrial began in 2008, a key part of the Crown’s original case — testimony from witnesses whose memories had been refreshed through hypnosis — was no longer admissible following a 2007 Supreme Court ruling.

Convicted serial killer and Scarborough Rapist Paul Bernardo was also raised as a possible suspect in Bain’s disappearance, although police maintained he wasn’t considered a reasonable suspect at the time.

In a videotaped prison interview in June 2007, Bernardo avoided directly answering Toronto police officers when questioned about Bain’s murder.

“The 800-pound gorilla in the room is — that is a life-25 sentence, you know,” Bernardo said .

Bernardo denied any involvement in Bain’s death and said he had never met her.

But Swain, a former CBC News investigative correspondent, says Baltovich’s ordeal with the Canadian court system is illuminating.

“Evidence that was allowed in his first trial is now, by law, not allowed in Canadian trials anymore,” she said. “When it came to his second trial the ruling was made that evidence that is gained through hypnosis is no longer admissible in Canadian courts.”

“Accepting somebody who had been hypnotized in court seems absurd now, but it didn’t at the time,” Morrison added.

Special explores three key dimensions of the case

During his initial trial, Baltovich’s lawyers suggested that the Scarborough Rapist — who had not yet been caught — could be a suspect in Bain’s disappearance and murder.

But police dismissed those claims because the Scarborough Rapist hadn’t murdered any of his victims in the late 1980s or early 1990s.

“During Rob Baltovich’s first trial, his defence lawyers were saying, ‘Why aren’t we considering that the Scarborough Rapist may be the real perpetrator here?’ ” Swain explained. “At the time, no one knew who the Scarborough Rapist was. Toronto Police said then, and they’ve maintained this, because the Scarborough Rapist didn’t kill anyone they didn’t think that was a reasonable suspect in Elizabeth Bain’s disappearance.”

Canadians learned the identity of the Scarborough Rapist in 1993, when Bernardo was arrested for the murders of Kristen French and Leslie Mahaffy. But Baltovich had already been sent to prison in 1992.

Dateline Canada will reexamine the evidence that led to Baltovich’s conviction. The episode will also revisit the evidence gathered during the Bain investigation and present previously unreported information surrounding her disappearance.

“There were young women attacked by Paul Bernardo in a part of Scarborough where Elizabeth Bain went missing around the same time. The last attack was the end of May in 1990 and she went missing in the middle of June, mere weeks later. There’s interesting information like that that I think we’re able to show people that illuminates this story,” Swain said.

“There’s some details about what was found in Elizabeth Bain’s car and one of them was a cigarette butt that no one else who was in her life was connected to.”

Morrison, who wasn’t involved in the creation of the homegrown spinoff, says he’s “thrilled” the long-running NBC show is expanding its footprint.

“We’ve done stories from Canada on Dateline ,” the Lloydminster-born Morrison said, “but it helps that we have a Canadian telling this story.” For one, the American production team isn’t always familiar with Canada’s justice system.

“The countries are very different,” he said. “The justice system is not the same and the attitude towards crime and punishment is different here.”

Morrison, who joined Dateline in 1995 after stints with the CBC and CTV, has explored trauma in people’s lives for more than three decades. As the stepfather of the late Matthew Perry , who died in 2023 following an accidental drug overdose, he’s also dealt with his own personal tragedy.

“It’s a personal thing with Matthew and it’s a personal thing with other people when they have something terrible happen to them,” he said softly.

Morrison says every victim and every story Dateline examines must be approached on its own terms.

“The uniqueness of this young woman (Elizabeth Bain). Who was she? What was her personality like? What would we think of her if we met her today? What would she be doing if she was alive now? Those are the kinds of questions that interest me,” he said.

After the two-hour special airs, Swain hopes new information will trigger a memory for someone watching at home.

“Elizabeth, even though she isn’t with us any longer, deserves to have her story settled. With luck, it’ll cause bits of information to come together in ways they hadn’t previously. Maybe that will lead us to an answer for everyone who cared about Elizabeth and still wonders what happened to her,” Swain said.

All these years later, even if new clues lead police to Bain’s killer, Morrison says her family will never find closure.

“There’s no such thing. You can have a conclusion. You can have a verdict in a case and say, ‘That solves that.’ It’s satisfying for people that were interested in it,” he said. “But closure doesn’t exist for the people who were involved in it. That goes on. Nothing really changes.”

Dateline Canada debuts on Nov. 26 at 8 p.m. ET/PT on Citytv and Citytv+ .

[email protected]

Read full story at source